
I am a holiday candy hoarder, and I think companies cash in on that. They put out all kinds of limited edition flavors and when they are gone, they are gone, forcing people to buy two bags in case they run out of the first one (cough). When I see a new flavor, whether it’s marshmallows, M&Ms, Hershey’s Kisses, or Oreos (which I still have yet to see these gingerbread ones?!), they usually end up in my cart. Then they sit in my pantry forever, leaving me with out-of-stock candy so I can’t post recipes since none of you can get the ingredients until next year (#foodbloggerproblems anyone?) So this year, I made an effort to do better and made No-Bake Fudgy Peppermint Cathedral Cookies, which uses both peppermint marshmallows and M&Ms for a holiday treat.
<

I had a bag of peppermint marshmallows and white chocolate peppermint M&Ms. I did Peppermint Rice Crispy Treats last year, so I wanted a new recipe. Then I hit a wall with the M&Ms. I didn’t want to do cookies since I did that for Halloween. I was going to do fudge, but I had such a bad day in the kitchen that night, I just knew it would fail. I had a recipe for Cathedral Cookies in my recipe box, so I started thinking. Mini peppermint marshmallows. That could work! Then instead of nuts, I used M&Ms.

I was a mess that night (literally). Chocolate ALL over my hands trying to roll the dang thing up. I was so skeptical that these were even going to work. I shoved it in the freezer and went to bed. The log set up beautifully and cut so easily. And everything smelled like peppermint. Of course, being as fudgy as they are, you can’t leave them out of the fridge too long or they are quite messy slicing.

The cathedral part of the name comes from the original use of colored marshmallows. After slicing, the colors represent a stained glass window found in cathedrals. This peppermint version is all dressed up for the holiday.

The best part about these No-Bake Fudgy Peppermint Cathedral Cookies is making them ahead of time and storing the log in the freezer until ready to serve. That is one less thing for you to do when planning those holiday parties.

No-Bake Fudgy Peppermint Cathedral Cookies
Ingredients
Instructions
Source: Adapted from Taste of Home magazine
Kim@Treats & Trinkets says
They look all pretty and festive. And lets be honest– messy things are the best kind.
Kayle (The Cooking Actress) says
Eeeeee these look so so yummy! And I love that they use seasonal candy ;)
liz says
These look great! My mom always makes the ones with the multi-colored marshmallows! Love them :)
Linda | The Urban Mrs says
Eekkk I hear you. I’ve been wanting to make something pepperminty since I have peppermint choco at home. This gives me an idea. Perhaps I can use that choco with regular marshmallow (I can’t find peppermint marshmallow). That log looks so gorgeous!
Carla says
Yes regular marshmallows would work! The M&Ms should have enough peppermint to carry over, but you can always add a touch of peppermint extract to the chocolate.
kelly @ kellybakes says
Is it bad that I can picture myself sitting on the floor, holding this log of chocolately minty goodness in one hand and just gnawing on the end of it with chocolate smeared on my smiling face and not a care in the world? Because I can. And I would.
Jessica | Oh Cake says
Call me crazy, Carla but why don’t you start doing recipes for making fun, seasonal candy?
Alice @ Hip Foodie Mom says
Oh my goodness!!! these look so good and festive!! I didnt even know peppermint marshmallows existed!!! Love this!!
Jennie @themessybakerblog says
Wee! These look so good. I love limited edition candy. Yum!
Brenda says
These look great,I usually make mine with the muli.colored marshmallows and a few drops of cream de menthe and Wilton’s milk choc candy melts.but I think these will be my new candy this year.